STATE OF MICHIGAN  
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS  
LANSING  
GRETCHEN WHITMER  
GOVERNOR  
ORLENE HAWKS  
DIRECTOR  
MICHIGAN BOARD OF REAL ESTATE APPRAISERS  
APRIL 28, 2023, MEETING  
UNAPPROVED MINUTES  
In accordance with the Open Meetings Act, 1976 PA 267, as amended, the Michigan  
Board of Real Estate Appraisers met on April 28, 2023, at 611 West Ottawa Street, Upper-  
Level Conference Room 4, Lansing, Michigan 48933.  
CALL TO ORDER  
Jumana Judeh, Acting Chairperson, called the meeting to order at 10:04 a.m.  
ROLL CALL  
Members Present: Jumana Judeh, Certified Real Estate Appraiser, Vice Chairperson  
James Hartman, Certified General Real Estate Appraiser  
Phyllis Howard, Public Member  
Jake Lew, Certified Residential Appraiser  
Catherine Quayle, Certified Residential Real Estate Appraiser  
Members Absent: Delbert Denkins, Certified General Real Estate Appraiser, Chairperson  
David Mook, Public Member  
Staff:  
Laury Brown, Senior Analyst, Compliance Section  
Kimmy Catlin, Board Support, Boards and Committees Section  
Andria Ditschman, Departmental Specialist, Boards and Committees Section  
Jennifer Fitzgerald, Assistant Attorney General  
APPROVAL OF AGENDA  
MOTION by Hartman, seconded by Lew, to approve the agenda with the addition of rules  
discussion and the removal of items 5A1 and 5A2.  
A voice vote was held.  
MOTION PREVAILED  
APPROVAL OF MINUTES  
BUREAU OF PROFESSIONAL LICENSING  
611 W. OTTAWA P.O. BOX 30670 LANSING, MICHIGAN 48909  
www.michigan.gov/bpl 517-241-0199  
LARA is an equal opportunity employer/program  
Michigan Board of Real Estate Appraisers  
Meeting Minutes  
April 28, 2023  
Page 2 of 4  
MOTION by Lew, seconded by Howard, to approve the minutes from September 20, 2022,  
as presented.  
A voice vote was held.  
MOTION PREVAILED  
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS  
Hearing Report  
David Dillon Bur  
MOTION by Quayle, seconded by Hartman, to receive the Hearing Report.  
A voice vote was held.  
MOTION PREVAILED  
MOTION by Quayle, seconded by Hartman, to discuss the matter.  
A voice vote was held.  
MOTION PREVAILED  
Discussion was held.  
MOTION by Hartman, seconded by Howard, to fine the Respondent $350 to be paid  
within 30 days. Failure to comply results in suspension of license until compliant.  
A roll call vote was taken:  
Yeas: Howard, Lew, Quayle, Hartman, Judeh  
Nays: None  
MOTION PREVAILED  
OLD BUSINESS  
None  
NEW BUSINESS  
Rules Discussion  
Michigan Board of Real Estate Appraisers  
Meeting Minutes  
April 28, 2023  
Page 3 of 4  
Ditschman informed the board that the rules have been promulgated and there have  
been inquiries related to opening the rules to address whether a market analysis can be  
used as experience and whether a market analysis meets USPAP standards 1 and 2.  
MOTION by Quayle, seconded by Lew, to open the rules.  
Discussion was held.  
A roll call vote was taken:  
Yeas: Howard, Lew, Quayle, Hartman, Judeh  
Nays: None  
MOTION PREVAILED  
Elections  
Ditschman ran the election for the chairperson.  
MOTION by Lew, seconded by Howard, to elect Judeh as the chairperson.  
A roll call vote was taken:  
MOTION PREVAILED  
Yeas: Howard, Lew, Quayle, Hartman, Judeh  
Nays: None  
MOTION by Hartman, seconded by Quayle, to elect Denkins as the vice chairperson.  
A roll call vote was taken:  
Yeas: Howard, Lew, Quayle, Hartman, Judeh  
Nays: None  
MOTION PREVAILED  
Master Resolution  
Ditschman presented the resolution with proposed additions.  
Discussion was held.  
MOTION by Quayle, seconded by Lew, to approve the resolution.  
A roll call vote was taken:  
Yeas: Howard, Lew, Quayle, Hartman, Judeh  
Nays: None  
MOTION PREVAILED  
Chair Report  
Michigan Board of Real Estate Appraisers  
Meeting Minutes  
April 28, 2023  
Page 4 of 4  
Judeh reminded the board to encourage their peers to apply for appointment to the board.  
Discussion was held.  
Department Update  
Ditschman stated that the bureau will hold the next Board Member Training on August  
22, 2023, via Zoom. All board members are welcome to attend.  
PUBLIC COMMENTS  
None  
ANNOUNCEMENTS  
The next regularly scheduled meeting will be held June 20, 2023, at 9:00 a.m. at the  
Ottawa Building, 611 West Ottawa Street, Upper-Level Conference Room 4, Lansing,  
Michigan.  
ADJOURNMENT  
MOTION by Hartman, seconded by Lew, to adjourn the meeting at 10:02 a.m.  
A voice vote was held.  
MOTION PREVAILED  
Minutes approved by the Board on__________________  
Prepared By:  
Kimmy Catlin, Board Support  
May 1, 2023  
Bureau of Professional Licensing  
;