DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY  
WATER BUREAU  
WATER RESOURCES PROTECTION  
(By authority conferred on the department of environmental quality by sections 3103 and 3106 of  
1994 PA 451, MCL 324.3103 and 324.3106  
PART 8. WATER QUALITY-BASED EFFLUENT LIMIT DEVELOPMENT FOR TOXIC  
SUBSTANCES  
R 323.1201 Purpose.  
Rule 1201. The rules in this part shall be used to establish toxic substance water quality-based  
effluent limits (WQBELs) for point source discharges that are protective of the designated uses of  
the surface waters of the state as established in R 323.1100. WQBELs for certain toxic substances  
may be very low and in some cases less than what current analytical techniques can detect or  
quantify. In some effluents, the low levels may not be amenable to regulatory control through end-  
of-pipe treatment technology in a cost-effective manner. To achieve compliance with the low  
WQBELs and associated regulatory requirements, the department is committed to, and strongly  
encourages, the use of pollution prevention, source control, and other waste minimization programs.  
End-of-pipe treatment for the low WQBELs which is extraordinary or beyond that which would be  
necessary if not for the low WQBELs will not be required by the department unless it is determined  
to be the most cost-effective means or the only means to achieve the applicable water quality-based  
effluent limit. The provisions of R 323.1103 may provide an alternative to extraordinary end-of-pipe  
treatment where such treatment would result in unreasonable economic effects on the discharger.  
The rules of this part shall not be used as a basis for establishing controls on the discharge of toxic  
substances from intermittent wet-weather point sources.  
History: 1997 AACS.  
R 323.1203 Definitions; A to L.  
Rule 1203. As used in this part:  
(a) "Acute-chronic ratio (ACR)" means a standard measure of the acute toxicity of a material  
divided by an appropriate measure of the chronic toxicity of the same material under comparable  
conditions.  
(b) "Acute toxicity" means an adverse effect that results from an acute exposure which occurs  
within any short observation period and which usually does not constitute a substantial portion of  
the life span of the organism.  
(c) "Acute toxic unit (TUa)" means 100/LC50 where the LC50 is determined from a whole effluent  
toxicity (WET) test which produces a result that is statistically or graphically estimated to be lethal  
to 50% of the test organisms.  
(d) "Aquatic life value" means a tier I or tier II value developed under R 323.1057(2).  
Page 1  
(e) "Bioaccumulation equivalency factor (BEF)" means the bioaccumulation potential for the  
toxicologically important chlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and chlorinated dibenzo-p-furans relative  
to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (2,3,7,8-TCDD) for use in calculating 2,3,7,8-TCDD toxicity  
equivalency concentrations in water as the 2,3,7,8-TCDD toxicity equivalency concentrations relate  
to deriving human health water quality values.  
(f) "Bioaccumulation factor (BAF)" means the ratio, in liters per kilogram, of a substance's  
concentration in tissue of an aquatic organism to its concentration in the ambient water where both  
the organism and its food are exposed and the ratio does not change substantially over time.  
(g) "Bioaccumulative chemical of concern (BCC)" means a chemical which, upon entering the  
surface waters, by itself or as its toxic transformation product, accumulates in aquatic organisms by  
a human health bioaccumulation factor (BAF) of more than 1000 derived after considering  
metabolism and other physiochemical properties that might enhance or inhibit bioaccumulation. The  
human health bioaccumulation factor shall be derived according to R 323.1057(5). Chemicals with  
half-lives of less than 8 weeks in the water column, sediment, and biota are not BCCs. The minimum  
BAF information needed to define an organic chemical as a BCC is either a field-measured BAF or  
a BAF derived using the biota-sediment accumulation factor (BSAF) methodology. The minimum  
BAF information needed to define an inorganic chemical as a BCC, including an organometal, is  
either a field-measured BAF or a laboratory-measured bioconcentration factor (BCF). The BCCs  
to which these rules apply are identified in table 5 of R 323.1057.  
(h) "Bioconcentration factor (BCF)" means the ratio, in liters per kilogram, of a substance's  
concentration in tissue of an aquatic organism to its concentration in the ambient water in situations  
where the organism is exposed through the water only and the ratio does not change substantially  
over time.  
(i) "Biota-sediment accumulation factor (BSAF)" means the ratio, in kilograms of organic carbon  
per kilogram of lipid, of a substance's lipid-normalized concentration in tissue of an aquatic organism  
to its organic carbon-normalized concentration in surface sediment in situations where the ratio does  
not change substantially over time, both the organism and its food are exposed, and the surface  
sediment is representative of average surface sediment in the vicinity of the organism.  
(j) "Carcinogen" means a substance which causes an increased incidence of benign or malignant  
neoplasms in animals or humans or that substantially decreases the time in which neoplasms develop  
in animals or humans.  
(k) "Chemical-specific water quality-based effluent limit" means water quality-based effluent limits  
that are based on an individual chemical.  
(l) "Chronic toxicity" means a concurrent and delayed adverse effect that occurs only as a result of  
a chronic exposure.  
(m) "Chronic toxic unit (TUc)" means 100/MATC or 100/IC25, where the maximum acceptable  
toxicant concentration (MATC) and IC25 are expressed as a percent effluent in the test medium.  
(n) "Clean water act" means the federal water pollution control act codified at 33 U.S.C. §1251 et  
seq., as amended.  
(o) "Daily maximum water quality-based effluent limit" means an effluent specific water quality-  
based effluent limit in an NPDES permit developed to protect aquatic life from acute chemical  
specific or whole effluent toxicity.  
(p) "Department" means the director of the Michigan department of environmental quality, or his  
or her designee to whom the director delegates a power or duty by written instrument.  
(q) "Detection level" means the lowest concentration or amount of the target analyte that can be  
determined to be different from zero by a single measurement at a stated level of probability.  
Page 2  
(r) "Discharge-induced mixing" means the mixing of a discharge and receiving water that occurs  
due to discharge momentum and buoyancy up to the point where mixing is controlled by ambient  
turbulence.  
(s) "Dissolved metal" means the concentration of a metal that will pass through a 0.45-mm  
membrane filter.  
(t) "Existing discharge" means any building, structure, facility, or installation from which there is  
or may be a discharge of toxic substances to the surface waters of the state that is not a new discharge.  
(u) "Final acute value (FAV)" means the level of a chemical or mixture of chemicals that does not  
allow the mortality or other specified response of aquatic organisms to exceed 50% when exposed  
for 96 hours, except where a shorter time period is appropriate for certain species. The FAV shall be  
calculated under R 323.1057(2) if appropriate for the chemical.  
(v) "Human cancer value (HCV)" means the maximum ambient water concentration of a substance  
at which a lifetime of exposure from either drinking the water, consuming fish from the water, and  
conducting water-related recreation activities or consuming fish from the water and conducting  
water-related recreation activities will represent a plausible upper bound risk of contracting cancer  
of 1 in 100,000 using the exposure assumptions and methodology specified in R 323.1057(4).  
(w) "Human noncancer value (HNV)" means the maximum ambient water concentration of a  
substance at which adverse noncancer effects are not likely to occur in the human population from  
lifetime exposure through either drinking the water, consuming fish from the water, and conducting  
water-related recreation activities or consuming fish from the water and conducting water-related  
recreation activities using the exposure assumption and methodology in R 323.1057(4).  
(x) "Intake toxic substance" means the amount of a toxic substance that is present in surface or  
groundwaters of the state at the time the toxic substance is withdrawn from the waters by the  
discharger or present in the water provided to the discharger by another facility.  
(y) "Intermittent wet-weather point source" means a point source discharge that occurs as a result  
of a rainfall or snowmelt event. An intermittent wet-weather point source includes a treated or  
untreated combined sewer overflow, but does not include a storm water discharge that is mixed with  
other industrial or commercial wastewater or an increased discharge from a municipal wastewater  
treatment plant due to a rainfall or snowmelt event.  
(z) "IC25" means the toxicant concentration that would cause a 25% reduction in a nonquantal  
biological measurement for the test population.  
(aa) "LC50" means a statistically or graphically estimated concentration that is expected to be lethal  
to 50% of a group of organisms under specified conditions.  
(bb) "Load allocation" means the portion of a receiving water's loading capacity that is attributed  
to existing or future nonpoint sources, including natural background sources.  
(cc) "Loading capacity" means the greatest amount of pollutant loading that a water can receive  
without violating water quality standards.  
(dd) "Lotic" means surface waters of the state that exhibit flow.  
History: 1997 AACS; 2006 AACS.  
R 323.1205 Definitions; M to Z.  
Rule 1205. As used in this part:  
(a) "Mass load" means a wasteload allocation specified in units of weight per time.  
Page 3  
(b) "Maximum acceptable toxicant concentration (MATC)" means the concentration obtained by  
calculating the geometric mean of the lower and upper chronic limits from a chronic test. A lower  
chronic limit is the highest tested concentration that did not cause the occurrence of a specific adverse  
effect. An upper chronic limit is the lowest tested concentration which did cause the occurrence of a  
specific adverse effect and above which all tested concentrations caused such an occurrence.  
(c) "Minimum level" means the level at which the entire analytical system must give a recognizable  
signal and acceptable calibration point. It is equivalent to the concentration of the lowest calibration  
standards, assuming that all method-specified sample weights, volumes, and cleanup procedures  
have been employed.  
(d) "Mixing zone" means the portion of a water body in which a point source discharge or venting  
groundwater is mixed with the receiving water.  
(e) "Monthly average water quality-based effluent limit (WQBEL)" means an effluent specific  
water quality-based effluent limit in a national pollutant discharge elimination system (NPDES)  
permit developed to protect aquatic life, human health, and wildlife from chronic chemical specific  
toxicity or aquatic life from chronic whole effluent toxicity.  
(f) "National pollutant discharge elimination system (NPDES)" means a permit issued by the  
department to a discharger pursuant to sections 3106 and 3112 of 1994 PA 451, MCL 324.3106 and  
324.3112.  
(g) "New discharge" means any building, structure, facility, or installation from which there is or  
may be a discharge of toxic substances to the surface waters of the state, the construction of which  
commenced after July 29, 1997.  
(h) "Nonpoint source" means a source of a toxic substance to the surface waters of the state other  
than a source defined as a point source.  
(i) "Permittee" means the individual or facility that is issued an NPDES permit.  
(j) "Point source" means a discharge that is released to the surface waters of the state by a  
discernible, confined, and discrete conveyance, including any of the following from which  
wastewater is or may be discharged:  
(i) A pipe.  
(ii) A ditch.  
(iii) A channel.  
(iv) A tunnel.  
(v) A conduit.  
(vi) A well.  
(vii) A discrete fissure.  
(viii) A container.  
(ix) A concentrated animal feeding operation.  
(x) A boat or other watercraft.  
(k) "Pollution prevention" means eliminating or minimizing the initial generation of waste at the  
source or utilizing environmentally sound on-site and off-site reuse or recycling. Waste treatment,  
release, or disposal is not considered pollution prevention.  
(l) "Quantification level" means the measurement of the concentration of a contaminant obtained  
by using a specified laboratory procedure calculated at a specified concentration above the detection  
level. It is considered the lowest concentration at which a particular contaminant can be  
quantitatively measured using a specified laboratory procedure for monitoring of the contaminant.  
(m) "Raw water" means the surface waters of the state before any treatment.  
Page 4  
(n) "Receiving water" means the surface waters of the state into which an effluent is or may be  
discharged.  
(o) "Same body of water" means that, for purposes of evaluating intake toxic substances consistent  
with R 323.1211, the department will consider intake toxic substances to be from the same body of  
water if the department finds that the intake toxic substance would have reached the vicinity of the  
outfall point in the receiving water within a reasonable period had it not been removed by the  
permittee and there is a direct hydrological connection between the intake and the discharge points.  
Notwithstanding the provisions of this subdivision, an intake toxic substance shall be considered to  
be from the same body of water if the permittee's intake point is located on a Great Lake and the  
outfall point is in close proximity to the intake point and is located on a tributary of that Great Lake.  
In this situation, the background concentration of the toxic substance in the receiving water shall be  
similar to or greater than that in the intake water and a difference in any water quality characteristic  
between the intake and receiving water shall not result in an adverse impact on the receiving water.  
Groundwater sources of intake water can also be considered the same body of water if both of the  
following conditions are met:  
(i) The groundwater vents to the same surface water body where the discharge is located.  
(ii) The concentration of the intake toxic substance in the groundwater source is similar to the  
background groundwater concentration which exists at or regionally proximate to the groundwater  
source that is not attributable to any release at or regionally proximate to the source. Release shall  
be defined consistent with the September, 1996, revisions to section 324.20101 of 1994 PA 451,  
MCL 324.20101. Where a release has influenced the concentration of the toxic substance in the  
groundwater source, a same body of water determination shall be made by the department on a case-  
by-case basis. For purposes of this paragraph, the background groundwater concentration of the  
intake toxic substance shall be established at the time of permit issuance, reissuance, or modification  
based on data available to the department or data provided by the permittee from at least 1  
representative location.  
(p) "Surface waters of the state" means all of the following, but does not include drainage ways and  
ponds used solely for wastewater conveyance, treatment, or control:  
(i) The Great Lakes and their connecting waters.  
(ii) All inland lakes.  
(iii) Rivers.  
(iv) Streams.  
(v) Impoundments.  
(vi) Open drains.  
(vii) Wetlands.  
(viii) Other surface bodies of water within the confines of the state.  
(q) "Tier I value" means a value for aquatic life, human health, or wildlife calculated under R  
323.1057 using a tier I toxicity data base.  
(r) "Tier II value" means a value for aquatic life or human health calculated under R 323.1057 using  
a tier II toxicity data base.  
(s) "Toxicity equivalency factor (TEF)" means a reasonable estimate of the toxicity associated with  
a mixture of chlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and chlorinated dibenzo-p-furans relative to the toxicity  
of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin.  
(t) "Toxicity reduction evaluation (TRE)" means a site-specific study conducted in a stepwise  
process designed to identify the causative agents of effluent toxicity, isolate the sources of toxicity,  
Page 5  
evaluate the effectiveness of toxicity control options, and then confirm the reduction in effluent  
toxicity.  
(u) "Toxic substance" means a substance, except for heat, that is present in a sufficient  
concentration or quantity that is or may become harmful to plant life, animal life, or designated uses.  
These rules apply to all of the following toxic substances:  
(i) The priority pollutant and hazardous chemicals specified in the provisions of 40 C.F.R. §122.21,  
Appendix D (1990), which are adopted by reference in R 323.1221.  
(ii) The pollutants of initial focus specified in the provisions of 40 C.F.R. Part 132 (1995), water  
quality guidance for the Great Lakes system, which are adopted by reference in R 323.1221.  
(iii) The pollutants specified in table 1.  
(iv) Any other toxic substances that the department determines are of concern at a specific site.  
(v) "Translator" means a value used to predict the ratio of total or total recoverable metal to  
dissolved metal in a surface water of the state that is then used to derive a total or total recoverable  
water quality-based effluent limit using dissolved aquatic life tier I or tier II values.  
(w) "Venting groundwater" means groundwater that is entering a surface water of the state from a  
facility as defined in section 20101 of 1994 PA 451, MCL 324.20101.  
(x) "Wasteload allocation (WLA)" means the allocation for an individual point source which is  
developed in accordance with R 323.1209 and which ensures that the level of water quality to be  
achieved by the point source complies with all applicable water quality standards.  
(y) "Water quality-based effluent limit (WQBEL)" means an effluent limit developed for an  
NPDES permit that will ensure that the level of water quality to be achieved by the point source  
complies with all applicable water quality standards.  
(z) "Water quality standards" means the Part 4. Water Quality Standards developed under Part 31  
of 1994 PA 451, MCL 324.3101 et seq.  
(aa) "Water quality value" means a tier I or tier II aquatic life or human health value or tier I wildlife  
value developed under R 323.1057.  
(bb) "Wetland" means land characterized by the presence of water at a frequency and duration  
sufficient to support, and that under normal circumstances does support, wetland vegetation or  
aquatic life.  
(cc) "Whole effluent toxicity" means the total toxic effect of an effluent measured directly with a  
toxicity test under R 323.1219.  
(dd) "Wildlife value" means the maximum ambient water concentration of a substance at which  
adverse effects are not likely to result in population-level impacts to mammalian and avian wildlife  
populations from lifetime exposure through drinking water and aquatic food supply, using the  
methodology specified in R 323.1057(3).  
Table 1.  
1-amino-2-methylanthraquinone  
1-chloro-4-phenoxybenzene  
1,1,1,2-tetrachloroethane  
1,2-epoxybutane  
1,2,3-trichlorobenzene  
1,2:3,4-diepoxybutane  
1,2,3,5-tetrachlorobenzene  
1,3-butadiene  
1,3-propane sultone  
Page 6  
1,4-dioxane  
1,5-naphthalenediamine  
2-acetylaminofluorene  
2-aminoanthraquinone  
2-methyl-1-nitroanthraquinone  
2-naphthylamine  
2-nitropropane  
2,4-diaminoanisole sulfate  
2,4-diaminotoluene  
2,3,4,5-tetrachlorophenol  
2,3,4,6-tetrachlorophenol  
2,3,5,6-tetrachlorophenol  
2,4,5-trichlorophenol  
2,4,5-trichlorotoluene  
2,4,5-trimethylaniline  
3-amino-9-ethylcarbazole  
3-amino-9-ethylcarbazole hydrochloride  
3-(chloromethyl)pyridine hydrochloride  
4-aminobiphenyl  
4-chloro-m-phenylenediamine  
4-chloro-o-phenylenediamine  
4-dimethylaminoazobenzene  
4,4'-diaminodiphenyl ether  
4,4'-methylenebis (2-methylaniline)  
4,4'-methylenebis(N,N-dimethyl) benzenamine  
4,4'-thiodianiline  
5-chloro-o-toluidine  
5-nitro-o-anisidine  
5-nitroacenaphthene  
Abietic ccid  
Acetone cyanohydrin  
Actinomycin D  
Aflatoxins  
Aldicarb  
Aminoazobenzene  
Amitrole  
Anilazine  
Aniline hydrochloride  
Antimycin A  
1-amino-2-methylanthraquinone Aramite  
Azinphos-ethyl  
Azinphos-methyl  
Azobenzene  
Barban  
Bendiocarb  
Benomyl  
Page 7  
Bis(chloromethyl)ether  
Bromomethane  
Bromoxynil  
Butylbutanol nitrosamine  
Captafol  
Carbophenothion  
Chloramines  
Chlordecone  
Chlorfenvinphos  
Chlorinated dibenzofurans  
Chlorobenzilate  
Chloromethane  
Chloroprene  
Clonitralid  
Crotoxyphos  
Cupferron  
Cycasin  
Cycloheximide  
Cyclophosphamide  
Dehydroabietic acid  
Demeton  
Diallate  
Dibromochloropropane (DBCP)  
Dichrotophos  
Diethylhexyl phthalate  
Diethylstilbestrol  
Dihydrosafrole  
Dimethoate  
Dimethyl disulphide  
Dimethyl sulfate  
Dimethylhydrazines  
Dinocap  
Dinoseb  
Dioxathion  
Diphenyl ether  
EPN  
Ethyl chloride  
Ethylene oxide  
Ethylene thiourea  
Ethyleneimine  
Ethylmethanesulfonate  
Fensulfothion  
Fluchloralin  
Furathiazole  
Hexachlorocyclohexane  
Hexamethylphosphoramide  
Page 8  
Hydrazine  
Hydrazobenzene  
Hydrogen sulfide  
Hydroquinone  
Isonicotinic acid hydrazine  
Kanechlor C  
Ketene  
Lactonitrile  
Lasiocarpine  
Leptophos  
Malachite green  
Mestranol  
Methacrylonitrile  
Methomyl  
Methyl chloroform  
Methyl hydrazine  
Methylenebis(2-chloroaniline)  
Methylthiouracil  
Mitomycin C  
Monocrotaline  
Monocrotophos  
Mustard gas  
N-(2-hydroxyethyl) ethyleneimine  
N-methyl formamide  
N,N'-diethylthiourea  
N-nitroso-di-N-butylamine  
N-nitroso-N-ethylurea  
N-nitroso-N-methylurea  
N-nitrosodiethylamine  
N-nitrosomethylvinylamine  
N-nitrosomorpholine  
N-nitrososarcosine  
Neoabietic acid  
Nifurthiazole  
Niridazole  
Nithiazide  
Nitrofen  
Nitrogen mustard  
o-Aminoazotoluene  
o-Anisidine  
o-Anisidine hydrochloride  
o-Phenylphenol  
o-Toluidine  
o-Toluidine hydrochloride  
Octachlorostyrene  
Oxydemetonmethyl  
Page 9  
p-Chlorophenol  
p-Cresidine  
p-Nitrosodiphenylamine  
Paraquat  
Pentachloronitrobenzene  
Phenazopyridine hydrochloride  
Phenesterin  
Phenobarbitol  
Phenytoin sodium  
Phorate  
Phosazetim  
Phosmet  
Phosphamidon  
Piperonyl sulfoxide  
Polybrominated biphenyls (PBB)  
Polychlorinated naphthalenes  
Propyleneimine  
Propylthiouracil  
Rotenone  
Semicarbazide  
Semicarbazide hydrochloride  
Silvex  
Sodium fluoroacetate  
Sodium-o-phenylphenol  
Sulfallate  
Sulfotepp  
TEPP  
Terbufos  
Tetrachloroguaiacol  
Tetrachlorvinphos  
Tetranitromethane  
Thioacetamide  
Thiourea  
Thiram  
Triaryl phosphate esters  
Tributyltin (and salts and esters)  
Trichlorfon  
Trifluralin  
Trimethylphosphate  
Tris(2,3-dibromopropyl)phosphate  
Uracil mustard  
Urethane  
Vinyl bromide  
Ziram  
History: 1997 AACS; 2006 AACS.  
Page 10  
R 323.1207 Total maximum daily loads.  
Rule 1207. (1) The following general principles are applicable to establishing total maximum daily  
loads (TMDLs) for toxic substances in the surface waters of the state, with the exception of whole  
effluent toxicity:  
(a) TMDLs shall ensure attainment of applicable water quality standards for the toxic substances  
for which they are established and shall, at a minimum, be developed in accordance with the listing  
and priority setting process established in section 303(d) of the clean water act and 40 C.F.R.§130.7.  
Where water quality standards cannot be attained immediately, TMDLs shall reflect reasonable  
assurances that water quality standards will be attained in a reasonable period of time, with specific  
controls on individual sources being implemented in stages. Determining the reasonable period of  
time in which water quality standards will be met is a case- specific determination considering a  
number of factors, including all of the following factors:  
(i) Receiving water characteristics.  
(ii) Persistence, behavior, and ubiquity of toxic substance of concern.  
(iii) Type of remediation activities necessary.  
(iv) Available regulatory and nonregulatory controls.  
(v) Department requirements for attainment of water quality standards.  
(vi) Technical and economic feasibility of attainment.  
(b) TMDLs shall include wasteload allocations (WLAs) for point sources addressed by these rules  
and load allocations (LAs) for nonpoint sources, including background, such that the sum of the  
allocations plus a specified margin of safety (MOS) is not greater than the loading capacity of the  
water for the toxic substance addressed by the TMDL. TMDL allocations are as follows:  
(i) Nonpoint source LAs shall be based on all of the following factors:  
(A) Existing toxic substance loadings if changes in loadings are not reasonably anticipated to occur.  
(B) Increases in toxic substance loadings that are reasonably anticipated tooccur.  
(C) Anticipated decreases in toxic substance loadings if the decreased loadings are technically  
feasible and are reasonably anticipated to occur within a reasonable time period as a result of  
implementation of best management practices or other load reduction measures. In determining  
whether anticipated decreases in toxic substance loadings are technically feasible and can be  
expected to occur within a reasonable period of time, technical and institutional factors shall be  
considered. These decisions are case-specific and shall reflect the particular TMDL under  
consideration.  
(ii) The sum of the WLAs is the portion of the loading capacity that is not assigned to an MOS or  
to nonpoint sources including background. National pollutant discharge elimination system  
(NPDES) permits for the point sources shall include effluent limitations consistent with WLAs in  
TMDLs.  
(c) If separate TMDLs are prepared for different, but overlapping, segments of the same watershed  
and the separate TMDLs each include WLAs for the same toxic substances for 1 or more of the same  
point sources, then WQBELs for that toxic substance for the point source or sources shall be  
consistent with the most stringent of the WLAs to ensure attainment of all applicable water quality  
standards.  
(d) Each TMDL shall include an MOS sufficient to account for technical uncertainties in  
establishing the TMDL and shall describe the manner in which the MOS is determined and  
incorporated into the TMDL. The MOS may be provided by leaving a portion of the loading capacity  
Page 11  
unallocated or by using conservative modeling assumptions to establish WLAs and LAs. The MOS  
may also include reserved allocation for future growth.  
(e) Where appropriate and where sufficient data or sediment criteria are available, TMDLs shall  
prevent the accumulation of the toxic substance in the sediment to levels injurious to designated or  
existing uses and shall reflect contributions to the water column from the sediments.  
(f) Where appropriate and where sufficient data are available, TMDLs shall reflect loadings of toxic  
substance discharges resulting from wet- weather events  
(g) The representative background concentration of toxic substances to develop TMDLs and WLAs  
calculated in the absence of a TMDL shall be established as follows:  
(i) "Background" represents all toxic substance loadings as specified by the following:  
(A) Flow from upstream waters into the specified watershed, water body, or water body segment  
for which a TMDL or WLA in the absence of a TMDL is being developed.  
(B) Enter the specified watershed, water body, or water body segment through atmospheric  
deposition, chemical reaction, or sediment release or resuspension.  
(ii) When determining what available data are acceptable for use in calculating background, the  
department shall use its best professional judgment, including consideration of the sampling location  
and the reliability of the data through comparison, in part, to detection and quantification levels.  
When data in more than 1 of the data sets or categories described in paragraph (iii) of this subdivision  
exists, best professional judgment shall be used to select the data that most accurately reflects or  
estimates background concentrations. Toxic substance degradation and transport information may  
be considered when using toxic substance loading data to estimate a water column concentration.  
(iii) The representative background concentration for a toxic substance in the specified watershed,  
water body, or water body segment shall be established as the geometric mean of acceptable water  
column data or water column concentrations estimated through the use of acceptable or projected  
toxic substance loading data. When determining the geometric mean of the data for a toxic substance  
that includes values both above and below the detection level, values less than the detection level  
shall be assumed to be present at 1/2 of the detection level if the detection level is less than the lowest  
water quality value for that substance. If all of the acceptable data in a data set are below the detection  
level for a toxic substance, then all the data for the toxic substance in that data set shall be assumed  
to be zero. If the detection level of the available data is greater than the lowest water quality value  
for the substance, then the background concentration will be determined by the department on a case-  
by-case basis after considering all representative data, including acceptable fish tissue data.  
(h) If the margin of safety does not include a reserved allocation, then any increased loadings of the  
toxic substance for which the TMDL was developed that are due to a new or expanded discharge  
shall not be allowed unless the TMDL is revised in accordance with these procedures to include an  
allocation for the new or expanded discharge.  
(2) If the department develops an alternative type of assessment and remediation plan that meets  
the requirements of this rule and public participation requirements applicable to TMDLs, then the  
assessment and remediation plan may be used instead of a TMDL. The assessment and remediation  
plans may include lakewide management plans, remedial action plans for the areas of concern  
designated by the international joint commission, and state water quality management plans. Also,  
any part of an assessment and remediation plan that satisfies 1 or more requirements under section  
303(d) of the clean water act or implementing regulations may be incorporated by reference into a  
TMDL as appropriate. Assessment and remediation plans under this subrule shall be tailored to the  
level of detail and magnitude for the watershed and toxic substance being assessed.  
(3) Design flows for establishing TMDLs in lotic waters are given in R 323.1090.  
Page 12  
(4) If a TMDL has been established for a water body receiving the direct discharge of point sources,  
then the chronic WLA for each point source shall equal a fraction of the loading capacity assigned  
to point sources that discharge to the water body, but shall not be greater than the chronic WLA  
established by the procedures in R 323.1209, unless the TMDL reflects anticipated decreases in  
nonpoint source loadings through a phased approach to water quality standards attainment. Acute  
WLAs shall be established in accordance with R 323.1209.  
(5) It is not necessary to establish a TMDL for all waters that may be affected by a point source or  
nonpoint source before establishing a WLA or LA for the respective sources.  
(6) TMDLs and WLAs in the absence of a TMDL shall be based on the assumption that  
environmental fate or other physical, chemical, or biological factors do not affect the concentration  
of the toxic substances in the water column, unless both of the following occur:  
(a) Scientifically valid field studies or other relevant information demonstrate that degradation of  
the toxic substance is expected to occur during typical environmental conditions expected to be  
encountered.  
(b) Scientifically valid field studies or other information address other factors that affect the level  
of toxic substance in the water column including:  
(i) Sediment release or resuspension.  
(ii) Chemical speciation.  
(iii) Biological and chemical transformation.  
History: 1997 AACS.  
R 323.1209 Development of wasteload allocations for toxic substances.  
Rule 1209. (1) In the absence of a total maximum daily load (TMDL) established under R  
323.1207, or where consistent with a TMDL, the following procedure shall be used to  
calculate individual point source wasteload allocations (WLAs) for aquatic life, human health,  
and wildlife values consistent with the requirements of R 323.1211(2):  
(a) Chronic WLAs for discharges to lotic waters shall be developed for the toxic substance as  
follows:  
WLA = Zt (Qe + Qr) - (Qr)(Cr) Qe  
or  
WLA = (Zd)(T) (Qe + Qr) - (Qr)(Cr) Qe  
Where:  
Page 13  
Zt = water quality value developed for the toxic substance expressed as total or total  
recoverable.  
Zd = water quality value for aquatic life expressed as dissolved metal. Values expressed  
as dissolved, but for which a translator (T) is not available, shall be expressed as total or  
total recoverable for purposes of this subdivision.  
T = dissolved to total metal translator for aquatic life wasteload allocations. For the  
metals in table 2, T equals the given value or one derived from site- specific data. For  
metals not listed in table 2, T is equal to a translator derived by the department when  
sufficient information is available or from site-specific data.  
Qe = effluent design flow, which is the annual average design flow for municipalities  
and maximum authorized flow for other facilities, unless it can be demonstrated to the  
department that an alternate design flow is appropriate.  
Qr = flow of the receiving water allocated for mixing under R 323.1082. If a discharger  
has an intake upstream of the point of discharge, then Qr shall reflect the reduction in the  
design flow volume attributable to the intake.  
Cr = receiving water background concentration of the toxic substance developed  
under  
R 323.1207(1)(g).  
The lowest of the WLAs developed under this subdivision for the chronic aquatic life,  
human health, or wildlife values for each toxic substance shall be the basis for the water  
quality-based effluent limit (WQBEL) as specified in R 323.1211(4)(a).  
T
a
b
l
e
2
.
Dissolved to total metal translators for aquatic life wasteload allocations.  
Toxic Substance  
Translator (T)  
Cadmium...................................................2.1  
Chromium..................................................1.5  
Copper.......................................................1.5  
Lead..........................................................4.5  
Nickel........................................................1.1  
Zinc...........................................................2.1  
(b) Chronic WLAs for discharges to the Great Lakes and inland lakes shall be developed  
for a toxic substance as follows:  
WLA = (Zt)(1 + Q) - (Cr)(Q)  
Page 14  
or  
WLA = (Zd)(T)(1 + Q) -  
(Cr)(Q) Where:  
Zt = the lowest water quality value developed for the toxic substance expressed  
as total or total recoverable.  
Zd = water quality value for aquatic life expressed as dissolved metal. Values expressed  
as dissolved, but for which a translator (T) is not available, shall be expressed as total or  
total recoverable for purposes of this subdivision.  
T = dissolved to total translator for aquatic life wasteload allocations. For the metals  
in table 2, T equals the given value or one derived from site- specific data. For the  
metals not listed in table 2, T is equal to a translator derived by the department when  
sufficient information is available or from site-specific data.  
Q = number of parts receiving water allocated for mixing under R 323.1082(5).  
Cr = receiving water background concentrationof the toxic substance developed  
under R 323.1207(1)(g).  
The lowest of the WLAs developed under this subdivision for the chronic aquatic  
life, human health, or wildlife values for each toxic substance shall be the basis for the  
WQBEL as specified in R 323.1211(4)(a).  
(2) If the receiving water background concentration (Cr) of a toxic substance exceeds the  
most stringent applicable water quality value for that substance, then the WLA shall be  
established equal to the most stringent water quality values, unless the provisions of  
323.1211(7)(d) allow for a different approach.  
R
(3) WLAs based upon acute aquatic life protection shall not exceed the following acute  
WLA, unless it can be demonstrated to the department that a higher level is acceptable  
under R 323.1082(1). :  
WLA = (At)  
or  
WLA = (Ad)(T)  
Where:  
At = the final acute value developed for the toxic substance under R 323.1057  
expressed as total or total recoverable.  
Ad = final acute value for aquatic life expressed as dissolved metal under R  
323.1057. Values expressed as dissolved, but for which a translator (T) is not available,  
shall be expressed as total or total recoverable for purposes of this subdivision.  
T= dissolved to total translator for aquatic life wasteload allocations. For the  
metals in table 2, T equals the given value or one derived from site- specific data. For  
the metals not listed in table 2, T is equal to a translator derived by the department  
when sufficient information is available or from site-specific data.  
Page 15  
(4) When establishing WLAs based on human health values for individual point source  
discharges, the potential interaction between multiple toxic substances in the effluent  
shall be addressed by the following provisions:  
(a) If an effluent contains carcinogensfor which availablescientific informationsupports  
a reasonable assumption that the toxic substances produce the same type of cancer through  
the same mechanism of action and for which WQBELs are required pursuant to R 323.1211  
on an individual basis, then the total incremental risk created by the effluent in the surface  
waters of the state after mixing with the allowable receiving water body volume specified  
in R 323.1082 shall not exceed 1 X 10-5for individual carcinogens and 1 X 10-4for the total  
effluent. This additivity provision shall be implemented on a case-by-case basis and shall  
be evaluated at each facility independent of other carcinogens that may be present in the  
receiving water.  
(b) If an effluent contains 2 or more noncarcinogens for which available scientific  
information supports a reasonable assumption that the toxic substances produce the same  
adverse effects through the same mechanisms of action and for which WQBELs are  
required under R 323.1211 on an individual basis, then the noncarcinogenic effects of the  
chemicals may be assumed additive and considered by the department when calculating  
WLAs protective of human health. This subdivision shall be implemented on a case-by-  
case basis and shall be evaluated at each facility independent of other noncarcinogens that  
may be present in the receiving stream.  
(c) Notwithstanding the requirements in subdivisions (a) and (b) of this subrule,  
human health-based WLAs for the chlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins (CDDs) and  
chlorinated dibenzofurans (CDFs) listed in table 2 shall be calculated using the  
following procedures:  
(i) The human cancer value and human noncancer value for 2,3,7,8-TCDD shall be used  
consistent with the procedures in subrules (1) and (2) of this rule to calculate total 2,3,7,8-  
TCDD toxicity equivalence WLAs for effluents.  
(ii) The toxicity equivalency factors (TEFs) and bioaccumulation equivalency factors  
(BEFs) in table 2 3 shall be used to calculate a 2,3,7,8- TCDD toxicity equivalence  
concentration for an effluent when implementing the WLAs derived in paragraph (i) of  
this subdivision. The equation for calculating the 2,3,7,8-TCDD toxicity equivalence  
concentration in an effluent is as follows:  
(TEC)  
TCDD  
= Σ(C) (TEF) (BEF)  
x x x  
Where:  
(TEC)  
= 2,3,7,8-TCDD toxicity equivalence concentration in the  
TCDD  
discharge.  
(C) = the concentration of congener x in the discharge.  
x
(TEF) = toxicity equivalency factor for congener x.  
x
(BEF) = bioaccumulation equivalency factor for congener x.  
x
Table 3. Toxicity equivalency factors and BEFs for CDDs and CDFs.  
Congener  
TEF  
BEF  
2,3,7,8-TCDD  
1.0  
1.0  
1,2,3,7,8-PeCDD  
0.5  
0.9  
Page 16  
1,2,3,4,7,8-HxCDD  
1,2,3,6,7,8-HxCDD  
1,2,3,7,8,9-HxCDD  
1,2,3,4,6,7,8-HpCDD  
OCDD  
0.1  
0.1  
0.1  
0.01  
0.001  
0.1  
0.3  
0.1  
0.1  
0.05  
0.01  
0.8  
2,3,7,8-TCDF  
1,2,3,7,8-PeCDF  
2,3,4,7,8-PeCDF  
0.05  
0.5  
0.2  
1.6  
1,2,3,4,7,8-HxCDF  
1,2,3,6,7,8-HxCDF  
2,3,4,6,7,8-HxCDF  
1,2,3,7,8,9-HxCDF  
1,2,3,4,6,7,8-HpCDF  
1,2,3,4,7,8,9-HpCDF  
OCDF  
0.1  
0.1  
0.1  
0.1  
0.01  
0.01  
0.001  
0.08  
0.2  
0.7  
0.6  
0.01  
0.4  
0.02  
History: 1997 AACS; 2006 AACS.  
R 323.1211  
Reasonable potential for chemical-specific water quality-based  
effluent limits (WQBELs).  
Rule 1211. (1) Chemical-specific water quality-based effluent limits (WQBELs) shall  
be incorporated into a national pollutant discharge elimination system (NPDES) permit  
where the department determines that a toxic substance is or may be discharged into the  
waters of the state at a level that has the reasonable potential to cause or contribute to an  
excursion above any water quality value. The determination shall be made by developing  
preliminary effluent limitations (PELs) and comparing the effluent limitations to the  
potential effluent quality (PEQ) of the discharge.  
(2) PELs shall be developed for each toxic substance that the permittee reports as  
known or believed to be present in its discharge using the wasteload allocation (WLA)  
provisions specified in R 323.1207 or R 323.1209. At a minimum, PELs are required  
and shall be developed for the protection of aquatic life and noncancer human health  
effects where aquatic life values, human noncancer values, or the minimum data to  
calculate the aquatic life or human noncancer values are available. If there are  
insufficient data to calculate aquatic life or human noncancer values, then the  
department shall follow the provisions in subrule (6) of this rule. PELs shall also be  
developed for the protection of wildlife and human health cancer effects where human  
cancer values, wildlife values, or the minimum data to calculate human cancer or  
wildlife values are available.  
(3) The PEQs shall be determined by either of the following procedures:  
(a) If 10 or more representative facility-specific effluent samples are available that  
are greater than the detection limit, then the maximum PEQ shall equal the upper  
ninetififth percentile of all the representative daily discharge concentrations and the  
average PEQ shall equal the upper ninetififth percentile of all the representative 30-day  
average discharge concentrations. The upper ninetififth percentile of the daily  
Page 17  
discharge concentrations and 30-day average discharge concentrations shall be  
calculated as follows:  
P
= exp (mu + Z sigma )  
dn dn  
95  
p
Where:  
P
= upper ninetififth percentile of n-day average discharge  
95  
concentrations.  
d = ratio of the number of daily discharge concentrations less than the limit of detection  
to the total number of discharge concentrations.  
a specified  
n = number of discharge concentrations used to calculate an average over  
monitoring period (n=1 for daily concentrations and 30 for 30- day averages).  
exp = base e (or approximately 2.718) raised to the power shown between the  
parentheses in the P95 equation.  
Z = Z value corresponding to the upper p percentile of the standard normal  
p
th  
distribution.  
p = (0.95-d )/(1-d ).  
n
n
(sigmad)2 – (sigmadn)2  
mudn = mud +  
(1-d)  
+ ln  
= estimated log mean of n-  
day average discharge  
2
(1-dn)  
concentrations greater than the limit of detection. (Note: mudn = mud if n=1)  
s 2  
(sigmadn)2 = ln ( 1-dn ) 1+ m  
+
average discharge  
n - 1  
= estimated log variance of n-day  
n(1-d)  
n
concentrations greater than the limit of detection (Note: (sigmadn)2 = (sigmad)2 if  
n=1).  
2
mu = 1n m - 0.5 (sigma ) = estimated log mean of discharge  
d
d
concentrations greater than the limit of detection  
2
2
(sigma ) = 1n [1 + (s/m) ] = estimated log from variance of discharge  
d
concentrations greater than the limit of detection.  
ln = natural logarithm.  
m = mean of discharge concentrations greater than the limit of detection.  
s = standard deviation of discharge concentrations greater than the limit of detection.  
Reasonable potential for the discharge of a toxic substance to cause or contribute to  
an excursion above any water quality value will be considered to exist if the average or  
maximum PEQ exceeds any of the chronic or acute PELs, respectively, developed in  
accordance with subrule (2) of this rule.  
Page 18  
(b) If sufficient data are not available to use the process described in subdivision (a) of  
this subrule, then the PEQ shall be determined by identifying the total number of  
representative effluent samples, both detectable and nondetectable, and multiplying the  
maximum effluent concentration by the appropriate factor from table 3 4 developed by  
assuming a 0.6 coefficient of variation. Reasonable potential for the discharge of a toxic  
substance to cause or contribute to an excursion above any water quality value will be  
considered to exist if the PEQ exceeds any of the PELs developed in accordance with  
subrule (2) of this rule. For purposes of this subdivision, the department shall consider  
other scientifically defensible approaches on a case-by-case basis which are consistent  
with procedure 5.B.2 of Appendix F, 40 C.F.R. Part 132 (1995), which is adopted by  
reference in R 323.1221, for use in determining reasonable potential. If requested by the  
permittee, one such approach that is acceptable to the department is the prediction level  
concept specified in Gibbons, 1994, Statistical Methods for Groundwater Monitoring -  
Wiley, New York where representative effluent data appropriate for use with this method  
is provided. If the prediction level approach is proposed for use with data sets containing  
values both above and below the detection level, then a process to address the less than  
detection values, that is acceptable to the department, shall be provided by the permittee.  
Table 4. Reasonable potential multiplying factors:  
95% confidence level and 95% probability basis.  
Number of Samples  
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Multiplying Factor  
1.8  
6.2  
3.8  
3.0  
2.6  
2.3  
2.1  
2.0  
1.9  
10  
11  
12  
13  
14  
15  
16  
17  
18 19  
1.4 1.4  
100  
1.7  
20  
1.7  
30  
1.6  
40  
1.6  
50  
1.5  
60  
1.5  
70  
1.5  
80  
1.4  
90  
1.4  
1.2  
1.1  
1.0  
1.0  
0.9  
0.9  
0.9  
0.9  
(4) If the analysis in subrule (3) of this rule demonstrates that the toxic substance  
concentration has a reasonable potential to cause or contribute to an excursion above any  
water quality value, then a WQBEL or WQBELs shall be established in the permit. For  
the purpose of an NPDES permit, a chronic or acute WLA based on a water quality value  
shall be equal to a WQBEL and shall be expressed using the following permit averaging  
periods:  
(a) Chronic WLAs for the protection of aquatic life, human health, and wildlife  
shall be expressed as monthly average WQBELs.  
(b) Acute WLAs for the protection of aquatic life shall be expressed as daily  
maximum WQBELs.  
Page 19  
Monitoring frequency to evaluate compliance with WQBELs shall be  
established by the department on a case-by-case basis.  
(5) Monthly average WQBELs shall be expressed as both a concentration value and a  
corresponding mass load. The mass and concentration limits shall be calculated using  
the same facility design flows. Appropriate adjustments may be made to address  
facilities that receive wet-weather flows. Daily maximum WQBELs shall be expressed  
as both a concentration value and a corresponding mass load for those substances  
identified in  
R 323.1205(u)(ii) and other toxic substances as appropriate.  
(6) For each toxic substance which a permittee reports as known or believed to be  
present in its discharge, and for which data sufficient to calculate tier II values for  
noncancer human health and aquatic life do not exist, all of the following provisions  
apply:  
(a) The department shall use all available, relevant toxicity information to estimate  
ambient screening values for the toxic substance that will protect humans from noncancer  
health effects and aquatic life from acute and chronic effects.  
(b) Using the provisions specified in R 323.1209, the department shall develop PELs  
based on the estimated ambient screening value and compare the PELs with the PEQ. If  
the PEQ exceeds any of the PELs, then the department shall generate, or require the  
permittee to generate, the minimum data necessary to derive tier II values for noncancer  
human health and aquatic life.  
(c) The data generated in accordance with subdivision (b) of this subrule shall be used  
to calculate water quality values. The values shall be used in calculating the PELs  
pursuant to subrule (2) of this rule for the purpose of determining whether a WQBEL  
must be included in the permit. If the department finds that the PEQ exceeds the PEL,  
then a WQBEL for the toxic substance shall be established in the permit consistent with  
R 323.1211.  
(7) All of the following conditions apply when considering intake toxic  
substances in establishing limitations in NPDES permits:  
(a) The department may determine that there is no reasonable potential for the  
discharge of an identified intake toxic substance to cause or contribute to an excursion  
above any water quality value if a discharger demonstrates, to the satisfaction of the  
department, or the department determines, all of the following:  
(i) The facility withdraws 100% of the intake water containing the toxic substance  
from the same body of water into which the discharge is made.  
(ii) The facility does not contribute a measurable increased mass of the  
identified intake toxic substance to its wastewater.  
(iii) The facility does not alter the identified intake toxic substance chemically or  
physically in a manner that would cause adverse water quality impacts to occur that would  
not occur if the toxic substances were left in- stream.  
(iv) The facility does not increase the identified intake toxic substance concentration,  
as defined by the department, at the edge of the mixing zone or if a mixing zone is not  
allowed at the point of discharge, as compared to the toxic substance concentration in the  
intake water, unless the increased concentration does not cause or contribute to an  
excursion above an applicable water quality standard.  
Page 20  
(v) The timing and location of the discharge would not cause adverse water quality  
impacts to occur that would not occur if the identified intake toxic substance were left  
in-stream.  
(b) If there is a finding under subdivision (a) of this subrule that a toxic substance in  
the dischargedoes not have the reasonablepotential to cause or contributeto an excursion  
above a water quality value, then a WQBEL is unnecessary and the permit may require  
monitoring necessary to demonstrate that the conditions in subdivision (a) of this subrule  
are maintained during the permit term. Unique situations for commingled waste streams  
at facilities will be addressed on a case-by-case basis.  
(c) Absent a finding under subdivision (a) of this subrule, the department shall use the  
procedures described in subrules (2) through (5) of this rule to determine whether a  
discharge has the reasonable potential to cause or contribute to an excursion above any  
water quality value.  
(d) If the background receiving water concentration of the intake toxic substance of  
concern exceeds the most stringent applicable water quality value for that toxic  
substance, then all of the following provisions apply:  
(i) If the facility meets the conditions in subdivision (a)(i) and (iii) to (v) of this subrule,  
then a no net addition limit may be established for the toxic substance of concern at a mass  
and concentrationthat are no greater than the mass and concentrationof the toxic substance  
identified in the facility’s intake water. In determining whether there has been an addition,  
recognized statistical concepts shall be considered. For toxic substances contained in the  
intake water provided by a water system, the concentration of the intake toxic substance  
shall be determined at the point where the raw water is removed from the same body of  
water, except that it shall be the point where the water enters the water supplier’s  
distribution system where the water treatment system removes any of the identified toxic  
substances from the raw water supply. Mass shall be determined by multiplying the  
concentration of the toxic substance by the volume of the facility’s intake flow received  
from the water system. Following establishment of a TMDL developed under R 323.1207  
for the water body segment encompassing the facility, any use of no net addition limits  
shall be consistent with the TMDL.  
Note: The Water Quality Guidance for the Great Lakes System, 40 C.F.R. Part 132  
(1995), indicates that a permit may not authorize no net addition limits that are effective  
after March 23, 2007. The preamble to 40 C.F.R. Part 132 indicates that the  
environmental protection agency (EPA) will revisit this requirement by March 23,  
2002, to consider possible extensions. After the redetermination by EPA, the  
department will consider modifying these rules to incorporate a phaseout date for no net  
addition limits, if still necessary.  
(ii) If the intake toxic substance in a facility’s discharge originates from a water that  
is not the same body of water as the receiving water, then WQBELs shall be established  
based upon the most stringent water quality value for that toxic substance.  
(iii) If a facility discharges an intake toxic substance that originates in part from the  
same body of water, and in part from a different body of water, then the department may  
Page 21  
apply the conditions of paragraphs (i) and (ii) of this subdivision to derive an effluent  
limitation reflecting the flow-weighted average of each source of the toxic substance.  
History: 1997 A A C S ; 2006 AACS.  
R 323.1213 WQBELs less than quantification level.  
Rule 1213. (1) If a water quality-based effluent limit (WQBEL) for a toxic substance is  
calculated to be less than the quantification level, then all of the following provisions apply:  
(a) The department shall designate, in the national pollutant discharge elimination system  
(NPDES) permit, the WQBEL as calculated.  
(b) The permit shall state, for the purpose of compliance assessment, the analytical  
method to be used to monitor the amount of toxic substance in the effluent and the  
quantification level. The analytical method specified shall be the most sensitive, applicable,  
analytical method specified in or approved under the pollutant testing regulations set forth  
in 40 C.F.R. §136 (2000), which are adopted by reference in R 323.1221, or other  
appropriate method that provides confirmation and verification acceptable to the  
department if one is not available under 40 C.F.R. §136 (2000). The permit shall also state  
that if an effluent sample is less than the quantification level, then the permittee shall be  
considered in compliance for the period that the sample represents if the pollutant  
minimization program (PMP) described in subdivision (d) of this subrule is being fully  
performed.  
(c) The quantification level shall be the minimum level (ML) specified in, or approved  
under, 40 C.F.R. §136 (2000), which are adopted by reference in R 323.1221, for the  
method for that toxic substance. If such ML does not exists, or if the method is not specified  
or approved under 40 C.F.R. §136 (2000), then the quantification level shall be the lowest  
quantifiable level practicable as established by procedures approved by the department.  
When establishing a quantification level, the department shall consider the achievability of  
the value by competent commercial laboratories. The permittee shall be given the  
opportunity to demonstrate that a higher quantification level is appropriate because of  
sample matrix interference.  
(d) The permit shall contain a special condition requiring the permittee to develop and  
conduct a PMP for each toxic substance with a WQBEL below the quantification level,  
unless the permittee can demonstrate to the department that an alternate technique is  
available and will be used to assess compliance with the WQBEL. The goal of the PMP  
shall be to maintain the effluent concentration of the toxic substance at or below the  
WQBEL. The department shall consider cost-effectiveness during the development and  
implementation of a PMP. The permit shall require the submittal of a PMP by the permittee  
that describes the control strategy designed to proceed toward achievement of the goal and  
shall include all of the following:  
(i) An annual review and semiannual monitoring of potential sources of the toxic  
substance.  
(ii) Quarterly monitoring for the toxic substance in the influent to the wastewater  
treatment system.  
Page 22  
(iii) A commitment by the permittee that reasonable cost-effective control measures will  
be implemented when sources of the toxic substance are discovered. Factors to be  
considered shall include all of the following:  
(A) Significance of sources.  
(B) Economic considerations.  
(C) Technical and treatability considerations.  
(iv) An annual status report. The report shall be sent to the department and shall include  
all of the following:  
(A) All minimization program monitoring results for the previous year.  
(B) A list of potential sources of the toxic substance.  
(C) A summary of all actions taken to reduce or eliminate the identified sources of the  
toxic substance. The requirements of paragraphs (i) to (iv) of this subdivision may be  
modified by the department on a case-by-case basis.  
(e) The permit may contain a special condition requiring fish tissue monitoring or other  
biouptake sampling, or both, or facility sludge monitoring to assess the progress of the  
PMP.  
(f) The permit shall contain a reopener clause indicating that any information generated  
as a result of the PMP described in subdivision (d) of this subrule may be used to support  
a request for subsequent permit modification, including revision or removal of the PMP  
requirement.  
(g) The quantification level specified in a NPDES permit pursuant to this rule shall remain  
in effect until the permit is modified or reissued. If the quantification level is reduced  
through a permit modification or reissuance, then the permittee may be eligible for a  
compliance schedule under R 323.1217 and a variance under R 323.1103.  
History: 1997 AACS; 2006 AACS.  
R 323.1215 Special conditions for bioaccumulative chemicals of concern (BCCs).  
Rule 1215. Conditions shall be established in national pollutant discharge elimination  
system (NPDES) permits that require the permittee to monitor for BCCs expected to be  
present in the discharge as a result of operations at the facility. The permit shall also contain  
a provision, consistent with R 323.1098, that prohibits the permittee from undertaking any  
action that would result in a lowering of water quality from an increased loading of a BCC  
unless an increased use request, including an antidegradation demonstration, has been  
submitted and approved by the department. The permit shall also require that the  
department be notified within 10 days of the permittee becoming aware that a lowering of  
water quality from an increased loading of a BCC has occurred.  
History: 1997 AACS.  
R 323.1217 Compliance schedules.  
Rule 1217. (1) If a permit issued to a new discharger contains a water quality-based  
effluent limitation (WQBEL) for a toxic substance, then the permittee shall comply with  
the limitation upon commencement of the discharge. Compliance schedules may be  
Page 23  
granted for new or more stringent WQBELs contained in a modification to the permit or  
subsequently issued permits.  
(2) Any existing permit that is reissued or modified to contain a new or more restrictive  
WQBEL for a toxic substance or a lower quantification level established under R 323.1213  
may allow a reasonable period of time, up to 5 years from the date of permit issuance or  
modification, for the permittee to comply with the new or more restrictive WQBEL or  
lower quantification level. When a compliance schedule goes beyond the term of a permit,  
an interim permit limit shall become effective on or before the permit expiration date.  
(3) If a permit establishes a schedule of compliance under subrule (2) of this rule that  
exceeds 1 year from the date of permit issuance or modification, then the schedule shall set  
forth interim requirements and dates for achievement of the requirements, as appropriate.  
(4) If a WQBEL for a toxic substance based upon a tier II value derived under R 323.1057  
is included in a reissued or modified permit for an existing discharger, then the permit shall  
provide a reasonable period of time, up to 2 years, in which to provide additional data  
necessary to develop a tier I value or to modify the tier II value. Information submitted to  
modify the tier II value may also include site-specific data and any such site-specific  
modifications shall be calculated according to the site-specific modification requirements  
of R 323.1057. The permit shall require compliance with the tier II limitation within a  
reasonable period of time, which shall not be more than 5 years after permit issuance or  
modification, and shall contain a reopener clause.  
(5) The reopener clause specified in subrule (4) of this rule shall authorize permit  
modifications if additional data have been provided by the permittee or a third party during  
the time allowed to provide the data and if the permittee or a third party demonstrates that  
a revised WQBEL for a toxic substance is appropriate. The revised WQBEL shall be  
incorporated through a permit modification and areasonable time period, up to 5 years from  
the date of modification, shall be allowed for compliance. If incorporated before the  
compliance date of the original tier II limitation, any such revised WQBEL shall not be  
considered less stringent for purposes of the antibacksliding provisions of section 402(o)  
of the clean water act (CWA).  
(6) If the specified studies have been completed and do not demonstrate that a revised  
WQBEL is appropriate, then the department shall provide a reasonable additional period  
of time, not to exceed 5 years, to achieve compliance with the original WQBEL.  
(7) If future studies other than those conducted under subrule (4) of this rule result in a  
water quality value being changed to a less stringent value, after the effective date of a  
WQBEL for that substance, the existing WQBEL may be revised to be less stringent if 1  
of the following provisions is met:  
(a) The less stringent WQBEL complies with sections 402(o)(2) and (3) of the clean water  
act.  
(b) The less stringent WQBEL complies with water quality standards or is consistent with  
a department-approved total maximum daily load in nonattainment waters.  
(c) The less stringent WQBEL complies with R 323.1098 in attained waters.  
History: 1997 AACS; 2006 AACS.  
R 323.1219 Whole effluent toxicity.  
Page 24  
Rule 1219. (1) For the purpose of evaluating the need for whole effluent toxicity  
(WET) limits or conditions in point source discharges, the narrative WET standard  
specified in R 323.1057(6) shall be interpreted as follows:  
(a) An effluent shall not exceed 1.0 acute toxic unit (TU ), unless a higher level is  
a
acceptable consistent with R 323.1082(1).  
(b) An effluent shall not cause or contribute to an exceedance of 1.0  
chronic toxic unit (TU ) in the surface waters of the state outside of any  
c
department-approvedmixing zone.  
(2) If the department determines under subrule (4) of this rule that the WET of an  
effluent is or may be discharged at a level that will cause or contribute to an excursion  
above the narrative WET standard specified in R  
323.1057(6), then the department shall implement all of the following  
provisions:  
(a) Establish a WET limitation or limitations consistent with subrule (5) of this rule,  
except as provided in subdivision (d) of this subrule, to assure both of the following:  
(i) Attainment of the acute WET provisions of subrule (1)(a) of this rule.  
(ii) Attainment of the chronic WET provisions of subrule (1)(b) of this rule.  
(b) Specify, in the national pollutant discharge elimination system (NPDES) permit for  
existing dischargers, on a case-by-case basis, a requirement to perform a toxicity  
reduction evaluation if representative  
toxicity data indicate persistent exceedance of the  
WET limitation.  
(c) Allow, with respect to any WET limitation established under subdivision  
(a) of this subrule, an appropriate schedule of compliance consistent with R  
323.1217.  
(d) Decide, on a case-by-case basis, if a WET limitation is not necessary if the  
department determines that chemical-specific effluent limits are sufficient to ensure  
compliance with any of the conditions specified in subrule (1) of this rule.  
(3) If the department has insufficient information to determine, under subrule (4) of  
this rule, whether the WET of an effluent will be discharged at a level that will cause or  
contribute to an excursion above the narrative WET standard specified in R 323.1057(6),  
then both of the following may be included in the permit:  
(a) WET testing requirements to generate the data needed to adequately characterize  
the toxicity of the effluent to aquatic life and any toxicity reduction requirements  
needed to meet the requirement of subrule (1) of this rule.  
(b) A permit reopener clause to establish WET limits if any toxicity testing data  
required under subdivision (a) of this subrule indicate that the WET of an effluent is  
discharged at levels that will cause or contribute to an excursion above any of the  
conditions specified in subrule (1) of this rule.  
(4) The department shall take into account the factors described in the permit  
condition regulations set forth in 40 C.F.R. §122.44(d)(1)(ii), which are adopted by  
reference in R 323.1221, and use representative data to evaluate the WET of an  
effluent. All of the following provisions for evaluating the reasonable potential of an  
effluent to exceed the requirements of R 323.1057(6) shall be applied:  
(a) The toxicity of the effluent shall be characterized consistent with all of the  
following provisions:  
Page 25  
(i) The results of acute toxicity tests collected within the same day for each species  
shall be averaged to represent 1 daily value. The maximum of all representative daily  
values for the most sensitive species tested shall be used for acute reasonable potential  
determinations.  
(ii) The results of chronic toxicity tests collected within the same calendar month for  
each species shall be averaged to represent 1 monthly value. The maximum of all  
representative monthly values for the most sensitive species tested shall be used for  
chronic reasonable potential determinations.  
endpoints,  
(iii) If data exist for either acute WET or chronic WET, but not for both  
then toxicity values for missing endpoints may be estimated using a default acute-chronic  
ratio (ACR) of 10.  
(iv) For purposes of deriving the daily acute and monthly chronic values in  
paragraphs (i) and (ii) of this subdivision, toxicity tests that do not yield quantifiable  
results (e.g. > = 1.0 TU or TU ) shall be assigned a value of zero.  
A
C
(b) The WET of an effluent is or may be discharged at a level that will cause or  
contribute to an excursion above the acute narrative standard specified in R  
323.1057(6) when:  
(TU effluent)(MF) > acute  
A
PEL  
Where:  
"TU effluent" is the maximum of the daily values determined pursuant to  
A
subdivision (a)(i) of this subrule.  
"MF" is the multiplying factor determined using the acute toxicity test results for the  
most sensitive species as specified in subdivision (a)(i) of this  
subrule. If none of the  
the MF shall be 1. Where there is at  
acute toxicity tests yield quantifiable results, then  
least 1 but fewer than 10 acute toxicity tests with quantifiable results, the multiplying  
factor taken from table 5 shall be based on a coefficient of variation (CV) of 0.6.  
Where there are 10 or more acute toxicity tests with quantifiable results, the multiplying  
factor taken from table 5 shall be based on a CV calculated as the standard deviation of  
the acute toxicity test results divided by the arithmetic mean of those test results. For  
the purpose of selecting a MF from table 5, “n” shall equal the total number of  
quantifiable and nonquantifiable acute toxicity test results. For the purpose of  
developing a calculated CV, acute toxicity tests that do not yield quantifiable results  
shall equal 1.0 TUa. If the calculated CV is <0.05, then the MF shall be 1.  
"Acute PEL" is the preliminary acute wet limitation derived for the facility under  
subrule (5)(c) of this rule.  
(c) The WET of an effluent is or may be discharged at a level that will cause or  
contribute to an excursion above the chronic narrative standard specified in R  
323.1057(6) when:  
(TU effluent)(MF) > chronic  
C
PEL  
Where:  
"TU effluent" is the maximum of the monthly values determined pursuant to  
C
subdivision (a)(ii) of this subrule.  
Page 26  
"MF" is the multiplying factor determined using the chronic toxicity test results for the  
most sensitive species as specified in subdivision (a)(ii) of this subrule. If none of the  
chronic toxicity tests yield quantifiable results, then the MF shall be 1. Where there is  
at least 1 but fewer than 10 chronic toxicity tests with quantifiable results, the  
multiplying factor taken from table 5 shall be based on a coefficient of variation (CV) of  
0.6. Where there are 10 or more chronic toxicity tests with quantifiable results, the  
multiplying factor taken from table 5 shall be based on a CV calculated as the standard  
deviation of the chronic toxicity test results divided by the arithmetic mean of those test  
results. For the purpose of selecting a MF from table 5, “n” shall equal the total number  
of quantifiable and nonquantifiable chronic toxicity test results. For the purpose of  
developing a calculated CV, chronic toxicity tests that do not yield quantifiable results  
shall equal 1.0 TUc. If the calculated CV is <0.05, then the MF shall be 1.  
"Chronic PEL" is the preliminary chronic wet limitation derived for the facility  
under subrule (5)(a) or (b) of this rule.  
(d) The WET of a new discharge shall be evaluated on a case-by-case basis  
considering all information available on the potential toxicity of the proposed  
discharge.  
(5) WET limitations shall be developed using all of the following provisions: (a)  
Chronic WET limitations for discharges to lotic waters shall be  
developed as follows:  
WET limit = W (Qe  
+ Qr)  
Qe  
Where:  
W = the condition specified in subrule (1)(b) of this rule.  
Qe = effluent design flow, which is the annual average design flow for municipalities  
and maximum authorized flow for other facilities, unless it can be demonstrated to the  
department that an alternate design flow is appropriate.  
Qr = flow of the receiving water allocated for mixing under R 323.1082. If a discharger  
has an intake upstream of the point of discharge, then Qr shall reflect the reduction in  
design flow attributable to the intake.  
(b) Chronic WET limitations for discharges to the Great Lakes and inland lakes shall  
be developed as follows:  
WET limit = (W)(Q + 1)  
Where:  
W = the condition specified in subrule (1)(b) of this rule.  
Q = the number of parts receiving water allowed for mixing under R 323.1082(5).  
(c) Acute WET limitations shall not exceed the condition specified in subrule (1)(a) of  
this rule.  
(d) WET limitations for facilities with overlapping mixing zones shall be evaluated on  
a case-by-case basis.  
(e) For purposes of an NPDES permit, WET limitations shall be expressed as follows:  
(i) An acute WET limitation shall be applied as a daily maximum and expressed in TU .  
a
Page 27  
(ii) A chronic WET limitation shall be applied as a monthly average and expressed in  
TU .  
c
(6) Monitoring frequency to evaluate compliance with WET limitations shall be  
established by the department on a case-by-case basis. Concerns with the effects of  
temperature and pH on ammonia toxicity under laboratory conditions during cold  
weather months will be considered in establishing monitoring frequency.  
this rule shall  
(7) All WET tests performed to implement or ascertain compliance with  
be consistent with methods established in 40 C.F.R. Part 136 (2000), which are adopted  
by reference in R 323.1221. Methods approved by the department shall be used when  
appropriate WET methods are not specified in 40 C.F.R. Part 136 (2000).  
Table 4 5. Reasonable potential multiplying factors: 95% confidence level and 95%  
probability basis.  
Coefficient of Variation  
n
1
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0  
6.2  
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
3.8  
3.0  
2.6  
2
3
4
2.  
2.  
2.  
1.  
1.  
3
1
0
9
8
5
6
7
8
9
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Page 28  
1. 1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1. 1.  
1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3. 3.  
9 0 2 3 4 6 7 8 0 1 2 3 4  
1
2
2
3
3
5
4
6
7
7
6
3
10  
11  
12  
13  
14  
15  
16  
17  
18  
19  
20  
30  
40  
50  
60  
1. 1.  
1
1. 1.  
6
1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 3. 3. 3. 3.  
8 9 1 2 3 4 5 7 8 9 0 1 2  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 3. 3.  
7 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0  
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
3
3
3
2
2
2
2
2
2
1
1
0
0
0
4
5
6
6
5
5
5
4
4
4
4
2
1
0
0
9
0
9
7
5
4
3
2
1
0
5
3
1
0
9
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1.  
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2.  
7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 5 6 7 8  
4
5
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2.  
6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 3 4 5 6 6  
4
4
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2.  
6 7 8 8 9 0 1 2 2 3 4 4 5  
3
4
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2.  
6 6 7 8 9 9 0 1 1 2 3 3 4  
3
4
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2.  
5 6 7 7 8 9 9 0 0 1 2 2 3  
3
4
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2.  
5 6 6 7 7 8 9 9 0 0 1 1 2  
3
3
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2.  
5 5 6 6 7 8 8 9 9 0 0 0 1  
3
3
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 2. 2.  
4 5 5 6 6 7 7 8 8 9 9 0 0  
2
3
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1.  
2 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 5 5 5 5  
1
2
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1.  
1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3  
1
1
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1.  
0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1  
0
0
1. 1. 1.  
1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1. 1.  
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0  
0
0
1. 1. 0.  
0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0.  
9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9  
0
0
70  
80  
1.0 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8  
1
.0  
1
.0  
0.  
9
0.  
9
0.  
9
0.  
9
0.  
9
0.  
9
0.  
9
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
0.  
8
90  
1
.
0
1
. 0.  
0 9  
0. 0. 0.  
0. 0.  
9
0.  
0.  
0.  
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8  
0. 0. 0. 0.  
0.  
0.  
0.  
0.  
0.  
9
9
9
7
7
7
100  
History: 1997 AACS; 2006 AACS  
R 323.1221 Adoption of standards by reference.  
Page 29  
Rule 1221. All of the following standards are adopted by reference in these rules, are  
available for inspection at the Lansing Office of the Department of Environmental Quality,  
and may be obtained as indicated:  
(a) "EPA Priority Pollutants and Hazardous Substances," 40 C.F.R. §122.21, Appendix D  
(2000). Copies may be obtained from the Department of Environmental Quality, 525 West  
Allegan Street, Lansing, Michigan 48933, at a cost as of the time of adoption of these rules  
of 5 cents per page and a labor rate of $20.18 per hour, or from the Superintendent of  
Documents, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC 20402, at a cost as of the time  
(b) "Table 6. Pollutants of Initial Focus in the Great Lakes Water Quality Initiative," 40  
C.F.R. §132 (1995). Copies may be obtained from the Department of Environmental  
Quality, 525 West Allegan Street, Lansing, Michigan 48933, at a cost as of the time of  
adoption of these rules of 5 cents per page and a labor rate of $20.18 per hour, or from the  
Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC 20402, at a  
cost as of the time of adoption of these rules of $43.00, or via the internet at  
(c) "Total maximum daily loads (TMDL) and individual water quality-based effluent  
limitations," 40 C.F.R §130.7 (2000). Copies may be obtained from the Department of  
Environmental Quality, 525 West Allegan Street, Lansing, Michigan 48933, at a cost as of  
the time of adoption of these rules of 5 cents per page and a labor rate of $19.78 per hour,  
or from the Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC  
20402, at a cost as of the time of adoption of these rules of $43.00, or via the internet at  
(d) "Appendix F to Part 132 - Great Lakes Water Quality Initiative Implementation  
Procedures, Procedure 5.B.2," 40 C.F.R. §132 (1995). Copies may be obtained from the  
Department of Environmental Quality, 525 West Allegan Street, Lansing, Michigan 48933,  
at a cost as of the time of adoption of these rules of 5 cents per page and a labor rate of  
$20.18 per hour, or from the Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office,  
Washington, DC 20402, at a cost as of the time of adoption of these rules of $43.00, or via  
(e) "Guidelines Establishing Test Procedures for Analysis of Pollutants," 40 C.F.R. §136  
et seq. (2000). Copies may be obtained from the Department of Environmental Quality,  
525 West Allegan Street, Lansing, Michigan 48933, at a cost as of the time of adoption of  
these rules of 5 cents per page and a labor rate of $20.18 per hour, or from the  
Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC 20402, at a  
cost as of the time of adoption of these rules of $61.00, or via the internet at  
(f) "Establishing limitations, standards, and other permit conditions," 40 C.F.R  
§122.44(d)(1)(ii) (2000). Copies may be obtained from the Department of Environmental  
Quality, 525 West Allegan Street, Lansing, Michigan 48933, at a cost as of the time of  
adoption of these rules of 5 cents per page and a labor rate of $20.18 per hour, or from the  
Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC 20402, at a  
cost as of the time of adoption of these rules of $43.00, or via the internet at  
History: 1997 AACS; 2006 AACS.  
Page 30  
;